Search Site   
News Stories at a Glance
Future of ag policy is at stake
Input costs are a top concern for farmers, Ag Barometer shows
5-year-old wins Best of Breed at Ohio National Poultry Show
Deere announces hirings and operational changes
Women that Farm brings meat and eggs to local customers
Deere 3720 diesel tractor pulled $28,800 at Jeff Boston auction
Data centers top Michigan Farm Bureau annual meeting agenda
New FFA president is from Ohio; stresses advocacy and leadership
Research station has assisted Ohio farmers for six decades
$205 million in projected sales comes from Illinois grain tour
Ohioan named FFA president at the organization’s 99th convention
   
Archive
Search Archive  
   
Future of ag policy is at stake
By TIM ALEXANDER
Illinois Correspondent

WASHINGTON, D.C. – The future of agricultural policy in the United States regarding trade, biofuels and the farm safety net has rarely been as uncertain as it is today. This is according to Robert L. Thompson, professor emeritus from the University of Illinois Department of Agricultural and Consumer Economics, who told a Farm Foundation Forum audience that when political and socioeconomic times change, ag policy must adapt and survive.
“Agriculture is a very risky business, and revenue is the product of two random variables not under the farmer’s control: price and income. The risk of a catastrophic drop in revenue can very easily put a farmer out of business,” said Thompson, a Farm Foundation Honorary Life Fellow who retired from the U of I in 2010 and now offers lectures and consultation on farm policy. “This is what I tell people who don’t know agriculture when they ask why we must have farm programs.”
Thompson noted that the USDA offers the “biggest welfare program outside of social security and Medicare in the form of food stamps” while posing the question of whether farm programs that distribute benefits in proportion to sales “really do that much” for beginning or low-income farmers. The concept of trade-adjustment assistance, originated by President John F. Kennedy in the Trade Expansion Act of 1962 and broadened in the 1980s by Sens. Dan Quayle and Edward Kennedy, may be in question moving forward, according to Thompson.
“Times are a’changing, and ag policy is going to have to change with the times. When we talk about farm policy and the short-run bias of Congress…there are several forces afoot that are going to force us to look carefully. Certainly, political realities are changing; we know who’s going to control the House, the Senate and the White House the next two years, but we don’t know who’s going to control them after 2028,” said Thompson, who was assistant secretary for USDA in the mid-1980s.
There are a number of areas of concern regarding ag policy as the House and Senate transition in January, according to Thompson. Will Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) tenets continue to extend into agricultural production and food safety policy? What priority will be placed on global trade, the environment, immigration, anti-trust laws, biotechnology, biofuels, rural infrastructure and deficit reduction?
Another area of concern for Thompson is whether executive mandates affecting agriculture enacted by one president can be quickly undone by another. “This puts priority on the fact that we need farm policy in farm bills and in the law, rather than just a paper signed by the president,” he said.
Thompson said he can envision federal budget constraint on ag spending coming in the next Congress and advised farmers to prepare. “The crunch is coming; Congress will have to address this with some combination of increased tax revenue and reductions in spending. Everything in the federal budget will be scrutinized,” he predicted. “The last time this occurred was in the mid-1980s, when after all else failed we made across-the-board cuts in federal expenditures under the Gramm-Rudman-Hollings (deficit control) Act.”
Federal lawmakers will be looking at spending in controversial areas such as nutrition assistance, food safety, the farm safety net (with a fresh eye on crop insurance and duplicate farm program payments made to farmers) and more, Thompson cautioned.
“One question will be why isn’t SNAP (the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program) under HHS (Health and Human Services) where the other federal welfare programs reside? Why isn’t food safety under FDA (Food and Drug Administration)? Wouldn’t it be more efficient to move the Forest Service into the Department of the Interior along with the national parks? What’s the appropriate division of labor between the public and private sectors of agriculture research? Why do six crops get 94 percent of all program supports?” Thompson queried. “I think we have to be prepared because there are going to be some very tough questions posed around a number of programs.”
He is also concerned about the future of the U.S. agricultural export share, which currently stands at about 23 percent of yearly U.S. agricultural commodity production. Without the current U.S. share of the global market, U.S. agriculture would have to “downsize significantly” in its overall production, according to the policy expert.
“De-globalization gets a lot of attention, but when you look behind the numbers are we really undergoing de-globalization, or is the rest of the world just restructuring around the United States’ flirtation with tariffs?” Thompson posed. “The key question is does the U.S. want to continue to be a player or are we going to cede the field to Brazil (and) Ukraine and downsize American agriculture?”
Another issue he will be following is what legislative priority the 120th Congress, which will be seated on Jan. 3, 2027, places on renewable fuels. “I believe biofuels’ role in the future is going to be more selective and concentrated in transport uses (that are) difficult to electrify. I think we’re going to see continued erosion of the gasoline market and in turn the market for ethanol,” Thompson said. “The competition for land between food and fuel is not over. I believe the future expansion of crop-based ethanol and biodiesel will be limited to verifiable life-cycle greenhouse gas reductions.”
Thompson offered examples of several needed reforms he would like to see the new Congress address. They include coordinating the farm safety net around net loss (payments linked to production won’t help starting and low-income farmers, he said), constraining ad hoc assistance, focusing insurance subsidies on the more catastrophic events, improving targeting and transparency, reviewing insurer compensation and costs, investing in better yield and loss information and making conservation part of risk policy.
The Farm Foundation Farm Safety Net Forum was held in person at the Flinchbaugh Center for Ag and Food Policy in Washington, D.C., and online on Nov. 17, 2026. It is archived for viewing at farmfoundation.org/forums.
11/20/2026